“Reputation” Disguised Within “Disinformation”

Published at BrandMap magazine Brand Shift Supplement, 2026
“Disinformation” has become life itself! Artificial intelligence defines it as follows: “Disinformation, in its simplest terms, refers to the deliberate and intentional dissemination of false or inaccurate information. The fundamental element underpinning this concept is the malice and calculated intent behind the spread of information.” The “malice” embedded within this definition echoes as an inner voice reverberating through the capillaries of daily life. Assuming information circulates through our veins instead of blood, shouldn’t we examine what is sought to be achieved and whose interests are being served when malice is married to information? Let me offer a more direct definition: Anything devoid of ethics!
For instance, concepts like greenwashing, artwashing, and whitewashing have entered our lives. Brands and corporations labeled with these terms play a game of “disinformation” with segments of society that are sensitive to human rights and ecological preservation.
The Zero Waste Foundation defines it as follows: “Greenwashing can be defined as a brand or organization claiming to act responsibly toward the environment while providing false and incomplete information on the matter. We can say that brands making misleading promotions by presenting themselves as eco-friendly without actually manufacturing in this manner are engaging in ‘greenwashing.’”
In short, this is an act of deception. Someone needs “reputation.” They observe that ecological sensitivity is among society’s rising values. Despite lacking this sensitivity themselves, they communicate as if they possess it! Because the fact that consumers take conscious steps to turn toward sustainable and eco-friendly brands directly affects their bottom line!
Greenwashing—disinformation seasoned with a sauce of reputation—thrived through green marketing. In truth, green marketing is a strategic construct, a legitimate business strategy. It has a naive justification: “We already manage our operations with an environmentally conscious business model.” It has legal and coherent foundations that say, “Here is the documentation.” A green marketing strategy can be considered a constructive path to raising public awareness, given the climate crisis and environmental factors threatening our world.
Companies and brands that think and act this way may be “naive,” but the competitive landscape is far from it! When consumer purchasing decisions shift at the checkout in favor of sustainable development principles—even showing a willingness to pay a premium—it can trigger brands that have not yet embedded this sensitivity into their systems in an entirely different way! This is precisely how we are introduced to greenwashing.
“If a brand or organization claims to be environmentally conscious and sustainable in its production and services, yet these claims do not reflect reality, it exploits the customer’s emotions. In this case, the brand engages in greenwashing by deliberately fabricating disinformation to expand its customer base.”
The marketing world discovered this trend through the market and consumer research it so frequently utilizes. The first study I witnessed was a report published in the UK by MORI in 1998. In the report, 29 percent of consumers stated they would not hesitate to choose products from brands with proven environmental consciousness.
“Although the concept of greenwashing was first coined in 1986 by environmentalist Jay Westerveld, it has become widespread in recent years. As evidenced by a 2015 Nielsen report, a significant 66 percent of consumers preferred sustainable brands and products. Reaching 73 percent in 2019, this figure continues to rise each year. Alongside customers, investors, fund managers, and banks are also moving to support brands demonstrating such commitments.”
Particular attention should be paid to the investors and fund managers mentioned in the final sentence of that quote. Because these are the very arenas where the content of disinformation is genuinely scrutinized. To safeguard its own “reputation,” the financial world insists on examining whether claims of environmental sensitivity reflect reality. For this reason, environmental commitments serve as primary evaluation criteria before the taps of syndicated loans—structured particularly for financing large-scale projects—are turned on. This is simultaneously linked to how company performance in these areas is reflected in financial analysts’ reports. It remains a pivotal issue influencing all financial conditions and processes, including loan interest rates.
The most notorious example of greenwashing entered business history as “Dieselgate.” As you will recall, Volkswagen, which marketed its vehicles in the United States as the “cleanest and greenest,” engaged in a sleight of hand by installing software in vehicles to manipulate and understate carbon emissions. Following investigations by independent bodies, the revelation that these vehicles actually emitted peak levels of harmful gases damaged the reputation not only of Volkswagen, but of the entire automotive industry. The crisis even extended to the country reputation of Germany, a nation renowned for automotive excellence!
The apparel and textile industry has likewise had its fair share of greenwashing. The environmental devastation caused by discarded clothing concerns all brands without exception. While there are certainly brands strictly implementing sustainability principles in their business models, their voices are completely drowned out in the competitive fog of greenwashing! The sector’s challenges are not limited to mountains of textile waste treated as discarded trash: child labor, poor factory working conditions, and the exploitation of cheap labor in impoverished nations attach themselves as opportunistic stains on brands. Yet right beside them stands a benchmark brand like Patagonia, whose practices have been taught in university curricula since the 1980s as a masterclass in management! There is a quote by management guru Peter Drucker that I admire deeply: “Management is doing things right; leadership is doing the right things!” I believe this is the exact crossroads where reputation management clashes with disinformation! Patagonia went down in history as the brand that “did the right things.” Other brands could have embarked on the very same journey!
When a corporation or brand exaggerates its environmental sensitivity and its responsibilities toward stakeholders—foremost human rights—it manifests as greenwashing. We witness this orchestrated primarily through public relations campaigns and marketing strategies. Quoting Mervyn E. King, Honorary Chairman of the Global Reporting Initiative, on social responsibility: the worlds of marketing, advertising, and public relations attempt across thousands of platforms to explain “how they made the money.” In other words, they strive to convince us that this is not pure disinformation, but rather disinformation infused with “reputation”!
When we turn another page of disinformation, we encounter “whitewashing”—the art of concealing the truth to transform corporate interests into perceived national interests, much like greenwashing, but through a different facade! Let us provide an example: Edward Bernays, lauded in university textbooks and praised as the “father” of public relations, sat at the head of the drawing board where CIA-backed coups were designed to overthrow democratically elected governments in countries like Guatemala and Chile under the guise of the “communist threat”! This occurred because the commercial interests of certain American corporations in those countries were at stake. Whitewashing was required to rebrand corporate interests as vital national interests, and Edward Bernays was the ideal operative for the task!
What Bernays was essentially practicing was Propaganda. In fact, the title of the book he authored in the 1920s was Propaganda! When the Nazis in Germany enthusiastically adopted and implemented his methods (managing perception without underlying truth), he became unsettled and coined the term “Public Relations.” Yet, he did not fail to define disinformation: “If you tell lies to counteract other lies, you are not really lying.” Bernays discovered that the essence was managing perceptions! And he knew this could be achieved through orchestrated events designed to become “news” in the press. Throughout his career, he provided recurring examples showing that disinformation only acquires “value” when coated in “reputation”—precisely because he skipped the station called “ethics” on his career journey!
We experienced another striking example of whitewashing in recent history: January 6, 2021, became a historic milestone for democracy. The US Capitol was breached, incited by presidential candidate Donald Trump. Convened members of Congress narrowly escaped harm. The “reputation” of a nation claiming to export democracy and democratic values was dragged through the mud. In subsequent months, never-ending investigations and court proceedings occupied the global spotlight like an episodic television series. Donald Trump—who failed to prove his disinformation claim that “they stole this election, we actually won” with any concrete evidence or findings—eventually returned to the presidential office for a second term! This represented a “counter-revolution” where disinformation triumphed over reputation as we know it. The very raw materials of reputation—ethics, fairness, transparency, responsibility, and accountability—did not alter voters’ decisions at the ballot box in the face of Trump’s long game and calculated disinformation strategy. The public believed Trump’s “story,” even after he was banned from dominant narrative-amplifying social media platforms like Twitter and Facebook, and despite the public being confronted with his jury conviction on all 34 felony counts related to hush money payments to conceal personal conduct prior to his first election. Trump blended disinformation with a “sauce of reputation”—and it succeeded!
Let us not overlook the third leg of the tripod: “artwashing.” Behind certain cultural and artistic activities that we eagerly attend, watch, and visit, we frequently find a deliberate “blanket” strategy. These arts and cultural events are deployed as blankets to cover up corporate transgressions concerning human rights, environmental degradation, consumer exploitation, and industrial waste. In other words, we are looking at corporate sponsorships and philanthropic activities from brands that exploit regulatory loopholes to conduct business as they please. Their actions are legal, technically compliant, and regulatory. However, that legality—an extension of corporate power and connections—completely bypasses the public-interest checkpoint of “ethics”!
Bernie Madoff, who defrauded investors of nearly $60 billion and later died in prison while serving a 150-year sentence, was one of the most prominent arts and culture philanthropists in the United States throughout the early 2000s. Museums, galleries, and art galas resonated with the Madoff name! Yet he was a fraudster.
The Sackler family, once among the foremost patrons of world-renowned cultural institutions such as MoMA, the Tate, and the Louvre, was pushed to the brink of bankruptcy. Purdue Pharma, owned by the Sacklers, stood at the epicenter of the opioid crisis that claimed the lives of over 500,000 people in the US through its aggressive marketing of OxyContin. Despite numerous warnings, the family kept the drug on the market and could not withstand the multi-billion-dollar lawsuits that followed. While the lawsuits were monumental, what deserves primary attention is that as soon as the corporate name became associated with these legal proceedings, renowned museums and cultural institutions across the globe returned their sponsorships and stripped the family name from their wings! A headline from that period captured the reckoning: “The Sackler Family Has Been Evicted from the Louvre Too.”
The British Museum ending its 27-year sponsorship relationship with BP is another case in point. The lead paragraph from The Guardian reported:
“BP’s sponsorship of the British Museum has ended after 27 years, according to new disclosures, concluding one of the highest-profile and most contentious corporate partnerships in recent years and signaling the fossil fuel giant’s near-total withdrawal from the UK arts sector.”
In Turkey, one does not need to look far to find prevalent examples of disinformation seasoned with reputation. When you examine the sponsors of events branded with “sustainability”—congresses, seminars, conferences, and summits—you immediately spot those waving right back at you! It is equally sufficient to look at the supporters of civil society organizations that accept these funds under the guise of “grants” for noble projects, often rationalizing that they could not operate without this corporate backing. Yet in corporate headquarters, strategic “hush money” budgets are systematically allocated for this exact purpose: some directed to conferences, some channeled into NGO partnerships showcased in television commercials, some distributed to select columnists and influencers, and others deployed to undermine United Nations COP summits.

How Can We Protect Ourselves Against Disinformation Seasoned with Reputation?

  1. Source Verification: Our starting point must always be the origin of information. Does the data stem from a trustworthy source, one with a verified track record that earns a passing grade?
  2. Independent Fact-Checking: Cross-referencing information against verified, independent sources. Platforms like teyit.org or civic monitoring initiatives like Oy ve Ötesi have performed vital work in this arena, while consumer platforms like sikayetvar.com serve as frequent reference points.
  3. Meticulous Label Reading: Critical literacy in examining labels is essential. If only a single ingredient in a product is natural or organic, labeling the entire product as “eco-friendly” constitutes greenwashing. Campaign initiatives by civil society groups, such as the Wheat Association for Supporting Ecological Living (Buğday Derneği – Non-Toxic Tables campaign), provide critical guidance regarding pesticides and health risks.
  4. Monitoring Regulatory and Watchdog Decisions: Oversight decisions by competition authorities, advertising boards, and standards agencies offer vital clues. The UK Advertising Standards Authority (ASA) notes that greenwashing complaints constitute a major share of consumer grievances, resulting in ad bans. In 2019, the regulator banned Ryanair’s advertisements claiming to be Europe’s “lowest emissions airline” due to insufficient substantiating evidence.
  5. Evaluating Buzzwords and Transparency: Buzzwords such as “eco,” “sustainable,” or “green” are deployed by companies to project an eco-friendly facade, yet they rarely align with rigorous scientific benchmarks.
Hiding data remains an art form in the greenwashing playbook. As noted in a BBC report:
“Fashion brands frequently spotlight clothing made from ‘sustainable’ fabrics while the vast majority of their production causes severe environmental damage. A brand claiming to be eco-friendly may omit supply chain emissions entirely—such as manufacturing overseas in factories powered entirely by coal.
This dynamic extends far beyond fashion. In 2007, the ASA banned a Shell advertisement implying that the company used its waste carbon dioxide to grow plants, having discovered that the emissions referenced constituted only a tiny fraction of Shell’s total output.
Similarly, paint brand Edward Bulmer claimed its products were the ‘most eco-friendly paint on the market,’ while concealing that several chemical ingredients were far from environmentally benign.
Packaging adorned with eco-friendly colors (typically green or blue) and natural motifs gives consumers the impression of sustainability. Yet product contents and production methods frequently contradict these claims. The words ‘natural’ or ‘organic’ printed on a plastic bottle do not make it environmentally friendly.”
Furthermore, sustainability reports are published in rapid succession as a corporate fashion. How much genuine credibility they carry remains debatable. The most effective litmus test is asking the company’s own employees about the report’s content: Have they read it? Are the stated policies genuinely practiced? Is carbon offsetting a sincere operational goal, a vague intent, or a fabricated fairy tale? Basic observation reveals the truth; transparency, traceability, and scientific validity must be our guides.
Another key indicator is the lifestyle of the CEO and executive leadership! How do their carbon, plastic, and water footprints look when managing their professional and personal lives? Sincerity regarding sustainability claims is easily discerned through these observations.
Environmental certification is important for shaping public perception, much like ISO standards served a similar function in past decades. However, fulfilling technical compliance during an audit is entirely distinct from embedding those principles into the living fabric of daily operations. The authentic sincerity we seek cannot be captured solely on a certificate or a printed report! At this juncture, the critical responsibility rests with those holding corporate communications and sustainability leadership roles. Guiding executive management ethically is a professional obligation. Internal audit, internal control, and independent external auditing mechanisms serve as strategic allies for professionals in these roles—not to deflect responsibility, but to document authentic commitment.
The framework known as ESG (Environmental, Social, and Governance) can be viewed as an attempt to approach this quest for sincerity in the language spoken by global finance. ESG criteria have entered our agenda as mirrors of corporate performance in guiding investments, acquisitions, and mergers. Yet practice reveals that ESG metrics alone have not eradicated greenwashing, artwashing, or whitewashing. We regularly see companies associated with these practices applauded in the headlines for their ESG scores!
Because ethics fails to deliver the final verdict! This is our fundamental impasse. We live in a world where doing the “ethical” thing often loses in corporate practice. No board applauds an executive who loses a tender because they refused to compromise ethical standards. In our country, conflicts erupt between local communities and developers of hydroelectric power plants—otherwise promoted as symbols of clean, renewable energy. Where solutions are enforced through brute intervention, the word “ethics” fails to serve even as a decorative object. Developers claim that everything is legally compliant within processes they control. Let us recall the words of philosopher Professor İoanna Kuçuradi:
“There can be ethics without law, but there must never be law without ethics—if our objective for law is to protect rights rather than serve self-interest. Yet today, the opposite occurs. Norms that violate human rights can be turned into law, strictly following official procedures. The understanding that law must derive from human rights, and therefore court rulings must be justified directly or indirectly by human rights, is still missing in most minds.
As the number of individuals possessing ethical literacy and human rights knowledge who make decisions grounded in this understanding increases, expecting conflicts to diminish is far from an illusion.”

Living Models of Ethical Practice

Let me share a few life examples of what it means to be ethical, so that the concept becomes tangible.
When Nobel Peace Prize laureate Muhammad Yunus launched the “microfinance” system in Bangladesh—defying the established conventions of the financial sector—many scoffed. After all, he was extending small loans of three to five hundred dollars (not thousands or millions) to individuals who lacked the collateral to step inside a commercial bank. These were craftspeople: bicycle mechanics, plumbers, carpenters. They needed funds to purchase tools, raw materials, and spare parts to earn a dignified living and bring food home to their families. Muhammad Yunus provided that opportunity. Tens of thousands of people built sustainable lives through these micro-loans, supporting their families. Moreover, without any collateral obligations, they repaid their debts on time, achieving a repayment rate of 96.7 percent! Muhammad Yunus translated ethical responsibility into the domain he knew best through microfinance. His starting point was how a philosophy of right and wrong was embraced in his personal worldview.
Jamie Johnson, an heir to the Johnson & Johnson pharmaceutical dynasty, did something radical: he directed a documentary film titled The One Percent. In this raw film, he investigated the environmental destruction and human rights abuses driven by the wealthiest 1 percent, probing how billionaires amassed their fortunes. Despite straining his relationship with his father, he leveraged the access his family name provided to interview figures ranging from Bill Gates and Milton Friedman to Steve Forbes and Robert Reich. Jamie questioned systemic income inequality; his ethical unease with inherited multi-billion-dollar wealth compelled him to make the film. Following its release, he became a sought-after speaker, addressing elite gatherings and speaking truth to power despite intense pushback.
The concept of “ethical trade” entered our lives, asserting that a business model could transcend greenwashing, artwashing, and whitewashing. While some brands exploited the term, it established a framework built around authentic philosophy.
Consider Green & Black’s, the British chocolate brand founded in 1991 by Craig Sams and Jo Fairley. From day one, they approached chocolate not merely as a consumer commodity, but as an ethical supply chain: “Green” represented environmental sensitivity, while “Black” symbolized the cocoa farmers’ labor and fair trade. The product had to be delicious while respecting nature and human dignity. Cocoa beans were cultivated through organic farming without chemical fertilizers or synthetic pesticides, safeguarding long-term soil vitality. In 1994, Green & Black’s became the first chocolate brand in the United Kingdom to earn Fairtrade certification, guaranteeing above-market prices, long-term purchasing commitments, and a strict stance against child labor. Early on, the brand asserted: “The ethical value of a product is measured not by its shelf price, but by the unseen stories across its supply chain.” This stood as an early practical model of stakeholder capitalism, establishing direct farmer relationships, supporting community education, and viewing growers as true business partners.
When Cadbury acquired Green & Black’s in 2005, skepticism followed: Could an ethical stance survive inside a corporate conglomerate? Would scale dilute core values? Green & Black’s refused to compromise its organic and Fairtrade standards, ultimately demonstrating that an authentic ethical stance is not an afterthought—when encoded into a brand’s foundational DNA, it generates lasting trust, reputation, and consumer loyalty.

Conclusion

Returning to the core of the issue: the pathogen of malice exists within human nature. In isolation, it harms only the individual. But when we carry this pathogen into institutions employing thousands of people, the reality shifts! When our decisions and operational processes project this malice onto society, the consequences are profound. We may generate immense wealth from these decisions; we may spend fortunes merely managing that wealth. Yet, as historical precedents demonstrate, the day arrives when reputation evaporates, leaving behind an untrustworthy institution. The pathogen of malice may eventually prompt a declaration of remorse. But what becomes of the resulting destruction?
If our decisions cause the loss of human lives, uproot thousand-year-old olive groves, deplete the earth’s regenerative capacity, and eradicate heirloom seeds—in short, if no livable world remains—is disinformation seasoned with reputation ever worth the price?
 

No Comments Yet.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *